« Marwan Barghouti for Gilad Shalit? | Main | When There's Nothing On The Horizon, You've Got Nothing Left To Prove »

10/11/2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

discount jerseys

But neglecting the removal of the best song the Strokes ever wrote and perhaps ever will write is pure laziness. And it's precisely that sense of laziness and self-satisfaction that defines the decline of Slate. A wag might say, It ain't too sma-haaaaaaart...

Mouse

The thing is that "New York City Cops" had absolutely nothing to do with the vast majority of Americans who bought the record. It played a negligible role in turning a generation of American college kids back onto rock n' roll, which is the main reason to argue the album's relevance.

The Nevermind argument is a bad one, but this is an odd argument against it.

s.

Not that I always agree with the guy, but as long as Chris Hitchens is still alive, he belongs on the non-idiot list with Lithwick, Weigel and Kaplan.

Barentw

I'm far more offended by all the Nirvana beatification than I am with nonsense about the Strokes. I've been putting up with that bullshit for over a decade now.

thehova

It's still an awesome and pivotal album without NYC Cops.

I'm not sure why everyone is so shocked by this slate article. I believe Rollins Stone ranked the album #2 of the decade.

The comments to this entry are closed.